Best Box Hair Dye

Unfortunately, we all are in the middle of a global pandemic. It is such a horrible thing that social animals are now practicing social distancing. However, the one good thing it brings is that it shifted people to the DIY (Do It Yourself) strategy. No matter if it’s daily household work or some other chore, people now prefer to do it all by themselves. The same is the case with beauty care.

Self-care is something on which no compromise is tolerable even during the pandemic, and hair always comes first. From all the hair treatments, hair dye is the most significant one. About 80 percent of women visit a hair salon for this purpose. However, a hair salon appointment is always a solemn commitment of time and money.

But now you can do satisfactory hair dye by yourself at home at even less than half price. So, why spend extra money and effort. Here comes the game of box hair dyes. No matter you are looking for a fresh change in the look or want to cover the gray root, box hair dyes are at hand.

The sad part is that box hair dyes had a bad reputation in the past and scare most people. So, they prefer going to a salon. But, it depends upon your choice. As long as you choose a well-known and famous brand compatible with your hair and scalp skin, nothing is more convenient and affordable than a box hair dye.

We understand that choosing one hair dye is no less than finding a needle in a heap of garbage. So, we are here to help you with your difficulty. We made research and prepared this list comprising the top-rated and best hair dye. You can choose any one of these dyes to get into a new look. So, let’s dive into the detail.

Our Top Pick

1.     Schwarzkopf Simply Color Permanent Hair Color

This effective hair color is our top pick. It uses an effective formula that is among the top choices of the reviewers. One reason is its ammonia, silicon, and alcohol-free formula. Dermatologists are confident that this hair color is very gentle on the scalp and does not irritate the skin. It is free from PPD.

Schwarzkopf Simply Color is a healthy combination of hydrating and conditioning constituents such as botanical oat milk, argan oil, and soy protein. So, no more risk of drying and damaging hair. Consumers can enjoy deep, beautiful, and vibrant color results from root to tip without compromising the health of hair. 

Its one cream pack guarantees 100 percent grey coverage and a long-lasting effect. However, if your hair is long, you should use two packs for ultimate results. Keep in mind that its darker tones are intense so if you want some optimal color, go for a lighter shade.


This color cream is a composition of aqua, ethanolamine, Cetearyl alcohol, resorcinol, and perfume. It also includes silica, sodium silicate, ascorbic acid, butylene glycol, ascorbic, and citric acid.

Its conditioner includes aqua, Cetearyl Alcohol, oat, Argania Spinosa Kernel Oil, shea butter, soy protein, and lactic acid.

2.     Garnier Olia Ammonia-Free Permanent Hair Color

This hair color is famous for its long-lasting effect. It is no less than a surprise that the hair oils that we use just to moisture the strands of our hair can also give a long-lasting effect to the hair color. The bright and permanent hair color by Garnier is the exact result of this fact. 

It’s common among the consumers that this hair dye’s color effect lasts until the new hair growth, and shampooing also does not affect it.

Olia is a unique ammonia-free formula comprising of 60 percent natural and derived flower oils. It keeps the hair hydrated and shiny. This dye transforms the coloring of your hair into a new sensorial experience. It is best for the permanent color and works well for nourishing the hair, temporary touchups, and enhancing the natural color.

Garnier takes its inspiration from nature and always uses products that cleanse, moisturize, and repairs your skin.

Garnier Olia comes in 34 different color shades. From blonde to rose red, it has the right one for you.


Its developer includes aqua, paraffin, oil, Cetearyl alcohol, hydrogen peroxide, rapeseed amide, hexadimethrine chloride, glycerin, phosphoric acid.

Its conditioner has Cetearyl alcohol, cetyl esters, behentrimonium chloride, and tocopherol. It also has chlorhexidine gluconate and sunflower seed oil.

3.    Jhon Frieda Precision Foam Color

This unique foam formula is perfect for brunettes. It is a shining medium brown color with a soft finish that nourishes and enhances brown tones for deep color saturation. It ensures a long-lasting effect and is strong enough to give 100 percent coverage to all the unwanted colors. It boosts your confidence in shiny and chest-nut brown shades.

The salon-quality color is now available at home without making a huge mess. It produces a thick foam that maximizes the penetration and color traction and prevents dripping. So, your clothes, bathroom, and hairline will no more be at the risk of stains with this hair color. It comes with a nourishing post color conditioner that moisturizes the hair and enhances the color for long-lasting lushness.

Its pack has all the essentials, including a colorant, developer, foamer, after-color conditioner, gloves, and instruction manual. Consumers are quite happy with its performance. According to them, this hair dye works wonders on thick and textured hair.


Its colorant is a combination of water, Disodium Cocoyl Glutamate, Ammonium Bicarbonate, Laureth-23, Propylene Glycol, Ammonium Hydroxide, Sodium Sulfite, Ascorbic Acid, and a few other elements.

Its developer includes water, Hydrogen Peroxide, Cetyl Alcohol, Steartrimonium Chloride, Myristyl Alcohol, Cetrimonium Chloride, Sodium Hydroxide, Etidronic Acid.

4.     L’Oreal Paris Professional Techniques Frost and Design Hair Color

This hair dye is famous for doing highlights of long hair. The frost and design’s pull-through cap dye has made the challenging process of highlighting the hair much more comfortable and more straightforward. It was typical that highlighting hair is impossible without a professional, and you can’t do it yourself. However, after using L’Oreal Paris, the consumers were surprised by the result.

This formula is exact and super easy to apply. The natural look that it gives to the hair is unbeatable.  Its kit comes with two hooks to customize your look. One hook is for the bold, and the other is for more precise highlights. You can also mix them up according to your desire to create a sun-kissed glow.

It is perfect to create precise highlights on long hair, and past shoulder length is ideal for it. L’Oreal Paris also includes the toning rinse that infuses some extra shine to the hair at the end. It makes sure that the hair will not look brassy.

The non-drip formula of this hair-dye creates no mess and works smoothly. The box also includes a tray, over-cap, and gloves.


Its lightening powder is the combination of Sodium Silicate, Potassium Persulfate, Sodium Persulphate, Acrylates, Urea, Kaolin, Ammonium Chloride, Magnesium Stearate, Polydecene, Sodium Metasilicate, and other elements as well.

The frosting protective cream includes Aqua, Ammonium Hydroxide, Cetearyl Alcohol, Hexadimethrine Chloride, Penta Sodium Pentetate, Fragrance, Linalool, and Geraniol.

The color toning rinse has water, Tartaric Acid, Polyquaternium-11, Fragrance, Chlorohexadine Dihdrochloride, Hydrochloric acid.

5.     Clairol Nice’n Easy Perfect 10 Permanent Hair Color

This hair dye is famous for its quick application. Those people who are always running short of time love Clairol Nice’n Easy Perfect 10 Permanent Hair Color. It claims to give the most advanced coverage to all the stubborn and pesky hair roots with fresh color just in 10 minutes. Moreover, this minimum effort lasts for 2 months.

Its innovative Tri-plex formula helps protect the structure of hair and prevents breakage. In addition to the built-in advanced conditioning formula, it also has an intensifying pre-treat serum and anti-oxidant infused color seal conditioning therapy. These ingredients ensure 100 percent coverage of all the grey hair and give them a young and fresh look. It dyes your hair in a perfect balance of color and tone.

The cream formula of this dye penetrates deep down and colors each strand in a precise method. Its lasting period is not as long as other hair dyes, but it is a go-to option when you are in a pinch of time. consumers are delighted with its quick results and unique color shades.

It comes in the form of a complete hair kit including high gloss color cream, color seal conditioner, color blend activator, and expert gloves.


Its color cream is a combination of shade 4 water, Propylene Glycol, Ammonium Carbonate, Sodium Glycinate, Fragrance, Cetearyl Alcohol, Ceteth-10 Phosphate, Resorcinol, Erythorbic Acid, and some other constituents.

The activating cream includes Water, Acrylates Copolymer, Hydrogen Peroxide, Methacrylate Copolymer, Disodium EDTA, Etidronic Acid.

6.     Revlon Total Clean Permanent Hair Color

This clean and vegan hair color is dermatologist-tested and free of all the harsh chemicals such as silicons, ammonia, parabens, sulfates, gluten, mineral oil, and phthalates. In addition to impressive color, Revlon Total Clean Permanent Hair Color also nourishes the hair.

It includes Cannabis Sativa seed oil, a derivative of hemp seeds, which has no psychoactive properties. It is gentle to your hair and scalp and does not cause any chemical reaction or irritation.

Its rich and vibrant colors cover all the gray hair, even the most stubborn ones. It lasts for about 6 weeks and gives a natural look. It is super easy to apply since the drip-free formula has reduced all the mess and makes it favorable to use at home.

This hair dye is enriched in botanical elements specific for different shades, such as brown hair dye includes sesame oil, black or dark hair dye has black tea extract, platinum, and blonde chamomile, and red hair color comprises of cranberry.

Your hair will become healthier and shinier with this dye.


This hair color is a composition of water, Laureth-2, Glyceryl Stearate SE, Ethanolamine, Glycerin, Polyquaternium-22, Isostearic Acid, Cocamidopropyl Betaine, Cannabis Sativa Seed Oil, Erythorbic Acid, Propylene Glycol, Lauryl Glucoside, Isopropyl Alcohol, Sodium Chloride, p- Aminophenol.

7.     Wella Color Charm Permanent Liquid Hair Color

This hair dye is perfect for a vibrant and long-lasting effect. It comes in 50+ mixable shades from which you can use one according to your choice. It ensures 100 percent coverage even to the most resistant grays.

This dye color is based on the liquid fuse technology. It saturates and fuses with the hair to provide an exceptionally fade resistant and accurate to tone hair color.  It is a time tested formulation that guarantees predictable and consistent results. It gives your choice color without boundaries in gold, neutral, ash, red, and warm shades.

With gentle fragrance and superb conditioning, Wella Color Charm Permanent Liquid is your perfect color partner.


It is a water composition, Oleic Acid, Ammonium Hydroxide, Isopropyl Alcohol, Toluene-2,5-Diamine Sulfate, Fragrance, Methylresorcinol, Disodium EDTA, Ascorbic Acid, Sulfate Ethanolamine, Sodium Sulfite, Aminophenol, and a few more constituents.

8.     Revlon Colorsilk Beautiful Color Permanent Hair Color

Revlon Colorsilk is an ammonia-free hair dye that guarantees 100 percent gray coverage. It is very gentle on the scalp and hair. This nourishing formula is enriched with silk amino acids and keratin that penetrates deep down the hair. You can achieve radiant shine, rich, and long-lasting hair color without going to the salon. It offers natural-looking and multi-tonal color from root to tips of the hair. It not only defines but also boosts your hair’s dimensions.

You will feel a clear difference in the condition and health of hair after using this dye.  This non-drip formula is very convenient to use without creating any mess. It is available in 41 different and natural shades. Whether you want to change your look or cover the greys, Revlon Colorsilk Permanent Hair Color can never go wrong.


Its colorant includes water, isopropyl alcohol, oleic acid, Lauramide Mea, Potassium Cocoyl, Sodium Sulfite, Wheat Amino Acids, Sorbitol, Hypnea Musciformis Extract, Tributyl Erythorbic Acid, Coumarin, Citronellol, Fragrance, Amyl Cinnamal, Oleyl Alcohol, and some other elements.

9.     Softsheen-Carson Dark and Lovely Fade Resist Rich Conditioning Hair Color

Softsheen-Carson Dark and Lovely Fade-Resistant Hair Color is an innovative formula that provides vibrant, fade-resistant color and shine. Its exclusive moisture seal technology and double conditioning power protect the natural hair while coloring. The conditioner comprises three fruit oils – avocado, shea, and olive – to provide intense nourishment from root to tip.

This permanent and non-drip hair color guarantees 100 percent grey coverage and protects the colored hair from breakage. Its luxurious and rich color lasts for more than 8 weeks. It allows you to celebrate different looks and styles with an array of unique colors. It works perfectly for all hair types like wavy, curly, straight, transitioning, or any other.


It is composed of aqua, Palm oil, fragrance, Behentrimonium chloride, apple fruit extract, and isopropyl alcohol. It also includes sodium benzoate, niacinamide, citric acid, pyridoxine HCL, olive fruit oil, Shea butter, sugarcane extract, lemon peel extract, and soyabean oil.

Tips for the Best Box Hair Dye

1.      Try to Get the Best Consultation

Before selecting a box of hair dye to your rack, go for an expert’s advice. If you don’t want to consult in a salon, there are many online options available. You can consider them. Self-selecting at home without any prior research can result in a bad experience not only with your hair but also with your scalp skin.

So, small professional guidance can help you make a sensible choice.

2.      Aftercare is Crucial

After getting the color according to your heart with box hair dye, some care is necessary to protect it and make it last longer. It would be best if you were super careful with your hair care regime. Ensure that the shampoos and conditioners you are using are compatible with the new color and texture of your hair. Otherwise, you will end up fading or destroying the whole look.

3.      Don’t Overdo It

Box hair dyes are perfect for enhancing and touching up the current color of hair. However, if you want a drastic change in hair color, try not to do it yourself. It would require some professional expertise.

For example, if you want your dark black hair to revamp into platinum blonde, it would not be easy. So, you should not play with it. However, you can transform your blonde hair into various bright colors. It would be much easier to do by yourself.

4.      Dirty Hair is Ideal

Hair dyes work more perfectly on dirty hair than on recently washed hair. The reason is that the natural oil of hair protects the strands during application and allows the color to penetrate more deeply and efficiently. So, if you want the best results, do it on unwashed hair.

What to Look for While Choosing the Best Box Hair Dye?

All the hair dyes vary in their composition. You should choose one according to the sensitivity of your skin and the texture of your hair. However, few factors are common that should be in the mind of everyone looking for a hair dye.


Ammonia is a healthy hair lightening component present in many hair dyes. It has a harsh smell and can be irritating and allergic to sensitive skins. So, try to find such an ammonia-free product. It will be suitable for all types of skin.

Novices who will dye the hair for the first time should also go for ammonia-free hair dye. They can get better results from it.


There are two types of colors. Temporary and permanent. Permanent colors last till the new outgrowth of hair, but temporary hair color fades away gradually. The lasting period of each color is present in the box. You can go for the second option if you are fond of changing the look over and over. And also, when you are not sure about how the color will look.

So, it is better to test the look first with temporary hair color rather than taking the risk of permanent hair color. However, if you are too lazy to dye your hair every month, it is better to have permanent hair dye.

Color Tone and Texture of Hair

Before choosing a hair dye, keep the color tone of your skin and hair in mind. The color you choose should complement your skin. Otherwise, it will look absurd. The texture of hair also matters because different hair textures absorb the color differently, so you should be aware of your hair and skin’s specialties before choosing a box hair color.

Read all the instructions and guidelines on the box carefully. It presents you with the results of different base colors. It should match your color tone as much as possible.


Hair dyes not only make you look young and presentable but also transform the entire look. Hair is the most noticeable trait in both men and women. So, it is crucial to keep them stylish and up to date as they reflect your personality.

Now, the process of hair dying has become rapid, easy, and affordable due to the introduction of box hair dyes. There is no longer a need for salons. You can do it all by yourself.

Millions of box hair dyes are available in the market, but their choice is the real problem. However, if you have been through this article, we are sure that it is no longer a problem because you might have selected one.

All the products mentioned above are the best, but our top pick is the Schwarzkopf Simply Color Permanent Hair Color. It is free of all harmful chemicals and is recommended by many dermatologists. Moreover, it provides 100 percent grey coverage and suitable for all types of skin and hair.

You can choose any of the above products for a unique and glamorous look. Happy Buying!